Would Union Workers be Willing to Pay $500 in Annual Dues for $11,000 More in their Paycheck?

Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on linkedin
LinkedIn

For the average union worker that is the trade off. 

Amazon is currently in the middle of yet another union challenge in its Bessemer, AL warehouse location of 5,800 workers.  The vote is happening now through the end of the month, and Amazon is using its unlimited resources to fight off this challenge, including hiring several “union avoidance” consultants like Russ Brown, and others to the tune of several thousands of dollars a day.  

According to the EPI, employers spend $340MM a year on union avoidance consultants to deny workers the right to organize in the workplace.  Amazon has been spending nearly $10,000 a day to thwart union efforts in Bessemer, according to Truthout.org.  Along with Mr. Brown, this includes law firm Morgan Lewis, and two other consultants Rebecca Smith and Bill Monroe.  It is important to note that companies like Amazon spend these large sums of money for a reason.  If successful, it saves these companies many MORE millions on what it would pay on workers pay and benefits in a union workplace.  

To deny workers the right to unionize, Amazon has recently launched its own “informational” website, #doitwithoutdues.  This site is aimed at employees who are deciding on this issue and submitting their votes this month.  This article will take a look at some of the points made by Amazon to counter the union effort and include a line by line fact check of those points.  Let’s get started here at “10 Union Facts & FAQ”:

Amazon: Who pays for a union?  You do. A union is a business that makes money from union dues collected from workers’ paychecks each month. 

FACT CHECK: This statement is PARTLY TRUE but does not tell the entire story.  See the remaining points below.

 

Amazon: Will a union provide more job security? No. A union cannot create job security or guarantee you will not lose your job.  When we work together to improve our business and provide service to our customers, more business is generated, meaning more job security for everyone.  

FACT CHECK: This statement is MOSTLY UNTRUE.  Although it’s technically true that nothing can be guaranteed, historically, over many decades, unions have provided the vast majority of its members with far more job security than non-union workplaces.  This may also may include pre-negotiated severance, guaranteed access to internal transfers to other jobs or company locations in the event of a specific location downsizing or closing.  

Furthermore, a member of a union generally cannot be fired “at will” and have the ability to collectively bargain even for your own.  Workers with union jobs can only be terminated for “just cause,” and the misconduct must be serious enough to merit such action.  Before an employee can actually be fired, he or she can go through a grievance process and, if necessary, arbitration.  Unlike non-union employees who serve at the will of an employer, and can be fired at any time for any reason, union employees have collective bargaining rights to due process whenever an employer takes disciplinary action. Union employees who are no longer on probationary status cannot be arbitrarily let go without just cause. Wrongful termination can be grounds for filing a grievance, human rights complaint or lawsuit.  Union employees can file a charge of wrongful termination if your employer illegally terminated your job or violated your union’s collective bargaining agreement (CBA) in the disciplinary process.  Lastly, a union may also negotiate on behalf of its members workplace safety and security protocols, as well as job guarantees (and pay increases for those “essential workers” taking the most personal risk) during and after a future pandemic, similar to COVD-19.

 

Amazon: Will a union provide better wages and benefits?  A union cannot guarantee better wages and benefits. With union negotiations, you could end up with more, the same…or less than what you make today.  

FACT CHECK: This statement is MOSTLY FALSE.  Although it’s technically true that nothing can be guaranteed, historically, over many decades, unions have provided a much higher average and median wage on behalf of its members vs. non-union employees.  According to the BLS,  among full-time wage and salary workers, union members had median usual weekly earnings of $1,095 in 2019, while those who were not union members had median weekly earnings of $892.  19% more than union members. This amounts to ~$11K more annually in base salary alone.  For $500/year in dues, this would provide at least a  2100%/year return on one’s union dues investment.  

Furthermore, according to the EPI, Black and Hispanic workers also get a larger boost from unionization. Black workers represented by a union are paid 13.7% more than their nonunionized peers. Hispanic workers represented by unions are paid 20.1% more than their nonunionized peers.  Unions and collective bargaining help shrink the Black–white wage gap, due to the dual facts that Black workers are more likely than white workers to be represented by a union and Black workers who are in unions get a larger boost to wages from being in a union than white workers do (Farber et al. 2018).1   Lastly, many studies have proven that the strength of unions benefits non-union workers as well.  This includes pay, benefits, family leave, safety protocols, and working conditions for all workers, helping to set a market for all.  

 

Amazon: Can we try a union out and get rid of it later?  Getting rid of a union, which is known as decertification, is a long and complicated process, and the law prohibits Amazon from helping you get rid of the union once they are in.  

FACT CHECK: This statement is MOSTLY TRUE but doesn’t tell the whole story.  More often than not, members choose NOT to decertify their union because collectively they are generally happy with the results their respective unions have yielded on their behalf.  In the rare event that collectively workers decide their union is not working well on their behalf, the process of decertification is also not as difficult as it used to be, according to the National Law Review. 

 

Amazon: Do I have to talk to the union representative?  No. Nobody can force you to talk to a union representative if you don’t want to.  FACT CHECK: This statement is TRUE.  It’s also true that by law companies cannot force you NOT to speak with the union representative, or retaliate against workers for any efforts to unionize.


Amazon: Do I have to vote for a union if I signed a card?  No. It’s your right to choose whether to vote for or against the union – even if you signed the card.  It is illegal for anyone, including a union, to threaten, intimidate, or coerce you into doing something you don’t want to do.  A secret ballot election will decide the outcome, and it’s important for everyone to vote.   

FACT CHECK: This statement is TRUE.  It’s also true that it is illegal for companies to threaten, intimidate, or coerce workers into NOT organizing a union.  It’s also true that it’s illegal for employers to retaliate in any way against employees for these actions.  Despite these laws, stories are numerous of employers engaging in some very borderline (at best) activities on this front, meaning in reality protections for workers here are weak.  For example, according to the EPI:

When workers at an Amazon warehouse in Staten Island, NY joined together and walked out to protest safety conditions, Amazon fired Chris Smalls, one of the lead organizers (Ivanova 2020a). His case is still being investigated by the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) (the presidentially appointed board that supervises union representation elections governed by the NLRA) and the New York State Attorney General.

Under current law, Smalls has no right to bring a lawsuit against the employer to assert his rights—he is entirely dependent on the Trump NLRB and its general counsel to pursue his case for unlawful termination. The general counsel is under no time deadlines or obligation to prioritize Smalls’s case. If the company is found to have illegally fired Smalls, it is simply required to offer him his job back, minus the wages he earned or could have earned in the meantime. There are no damages or penalties. In other words, Amazon is no worse off financially for illegally firing Smalls, but the company will have succeeded in removing a union activist from the workplace and creating fear among Smalls’s co- workers.

 

Amazon: What if I have a problem? Who do I talk to?  If a union and you have a problem, the union will decide whether to bring the issue to management.  

FACT CHECK:  This statement is TRUE.  However, historically on the whole this has proven to be a net positive for workers, who often feel like they don’t have a voice by themselves, but within the context of a large group of employees, feel more empowered to have representation to address and resolve important workplace issues on their behalf without fear of recrimination by their employer. This construct takes the onus off the individual employee to take these risks, and allow him/her to focus on their actual job.     

 

Amazon: Will a union provide a safety and appeals committee?  Amazon already has an Associate Safety Committee and appeals process.  You don’t have to pay hundreds of dollars per year in union dues in order to get what you already have.  

FACT CHECK: This statement is MISLEADING.  For example, last year, when workers at an Amazon warehouse in Staten Island, NY joined together and walked out to protest safety conditions during the early months of the COVID-19 pandemic, Amazon fired Chris Smalls, one of the lead organizers of that protest.  In fact, according to NPR, NY attorney general Letitia Games is suing Amazon for its lack of workplace safety protocols during the pandemic. The presence of a union could avoid these workplace safety problems that often lead to unnecessary human death, suffering and financial toll by setting and ENFORCING these protocols in place in the collective bargaining agreement.  

 

Amazon: Will I have to go on strike?  A strike is called when the union decides to do so.  If a union calls a strike, they expect that you will not go to work, even if you need to keep working to earn money to pay your bills.  Unions may even issue fines to employees who try to continue to work.  

FACT CHECK: This statement is TRUE.  If a union certification attempt is successful, those employees who are part of the union must strike along with their fellow union members if that’s what the majority of union members vote to do.  Part of the union’s job is to collectively bargain effectively with aims to avoid strikes, but in some instances they do happen. However, this dynamic generally gives the union and its members more leverage to negotiate more favorable terms in the collective bargaining agreement when it is reached.  This can often include better pay, benefits, family leave, and retirement.

 

Amazon: If the union calls a strike will I get paid?  If you go on strike, you will not be paid by Amazon and you will not be eligible for unemployment compensation.  FACT CHECK: This statement is TRUE but may not tell the whole story.  Many unions have a strike fund they keep on hand for members to meet their basic financial needs during times of work stoppages.  

 

Sources: EPI.org, BLS.gov, Truthout.org, NPR, National Law Review

   

 

More to explorer

become part of our

Solution

Help us fight income inequality!

Get in Touch

512ico

Thank You for your donation

Poor the Movie GoFundMe Donation Info

David Himmelstein

CUNY

Dr. David Himmelstein is a distinguished professor of public health and health policy in the CUNY School of Public Health at Hunter College, adjunct clinical professor at Albert Einstein College of Medicine, and lecturer in medicine at Harvard Medical School. He has served as chief of the division of social and community medicine at Cambridge Hospital.

Nick Hanauer

Pitchfork Economics

Nick Hanauer is one of the most successful entrepreneurs, investors, and managers in the Pacific Northwest with over 30 years of experience across a broad range of industries including manufacturing, retail, e-commerce, digital media and advertising, software, aerospace, health care, and finance. He is a co-founder and partner of Second Avenue Partners, a Seattle-based venture capital firm that provides management, strategy, and capital for early stage companies. 

Barry Ritholtz

Ritholtz Wealth MGMT

Barry Ritholtz has spent his career helping people spot their own investment errors and to learn how to better manage their own financial behaviors. He is the creator of The Big Picture, often ranked as the number one financial blog to follow by The Wall Street Journal, New York Times, and others.

Barry is the creator and host of Bloomberg’s “Masters in Business” radio podcast, and a featured columnist at the Washington Post. He is the author of the Bailout Nation: How Greed and Easy Money Corrupted Wall Street and Shook the World Economy (Wiley, 2009). In addition to serving as Chairman and Chief Investment Officer of Ritholtz Wealth Management, he is also on the advisory boards of Riskalyze, and Peer Street, two leading financial technology startups bringing transparency and analytics to the investment business.

Barry has named one of the “15 Most Important Economic Journalists” in the United States, and has been called one of The 25 Most Dangerous People in Financial Media. When not working, he can be found with his wife and their two dogs on the north shore of Long Island.

Richard Florida

City Lab

Richard Florida is a co-founder and editor at large of CityLab and a senior editor at The Atlantic. He is a university professor in the University of Toronto’s School of Cities and Rotman School of Management, and a distinguished fellow at New York University’s Schack Institute of Real Estate and visiting fellow at Florida International University.

Janet Gornick

CUNY-Stone Center

Janet Gornick attended Harvard University, where she was awarded a B.A. (psychology and social relations, 1980), an M.P.A. (Kennedy School, 1987), and a Ph.D. (political economy and government, 1994). She is currently a professor of political science and sociology at The Graduate Center, CUNY. From September 2006 to August 2016, she served as director of LIS (formerly the Luxembourg Income Study), a cross‐national data archive and research center located in Luxembourg, with a satellite office at The Graduate Center. Since September 2016, she has served as director of the James M. and Cathleen D. Stone Center on Socio‐Economic Inequality. The Stone Center includes the LIS satellite office, known as the US Office of LIS.

Ken Jacobs

UC Berkeley Labor Center

Ken Jacobs is the chair of the Labor Center, where he has been a labor specialist since 2002. His areas of specialization include low-wage work, labor standards policies, and health care coverage. He has recently worked on economic impact studies of proposed minimum wage laws for the cities of Seattle, Los Angeles, and San Jose, and conducted analyses of the public cost of low-wage work. Jacobs is the co-editor, with Michael Reich and Miranda Dietz, of When Mandates Work: Raising Labor Standards at the Local Level (University of California Press), an edited volume on the impacts of labor standards policies in San Francisco.

Steven Pitts

UC Berkeley Labor Center

Steven Pitts came to the Labor Center in August of 2001 from Houston, Texas. Steven received his Ph.D. in economics with an emphasis on urban economics from the University of Houston in 1994. His master’s degree is also from the University of Houston and he holds a bachelor’s degree from Harvard University. For the fifteen years prior to his arrival at the Labor Center, Steven taught economics at Houston Community College and, for five years, he was an adjunct lecturer in the African American Studies Program at the University of Houston. At the Labor Center, Steven focuses on issues of job quality and Black workers. In this arena, he has published reports on employment issues in the Black community, initiated a Black union leadership school, and shaped projects designed to build solidarity between Black and Latino immigrant workers. Currently, a major area of his work involves providing technical assistance to efforts in developing Black worker centers around the country.

April Sims

WSLC AFL-CIO

April Sims was elected Secretary Treasurer of the Washington State Labor Council, AFL-CIO by its affiliated unions in December 2018 and she began her four-year term on Jan. 5, 2019. She is the first woman of color to be elected as a WSLC executive officer.

April has served as the WSLC’s Political and Strategic Campaign Director since November 2017, working to develop shared agendas with labor and community partners, to advance strategic organizing campaigns (raising wages, naturalization, revenue reform, etc.), and to recruit, train and elect political champions for working people. She first joined the WSLC in September 2015 as Field Mobilization Director, working with WSLC-affiliated unions and community partners to support and encourage the participation of individual members with many different political, legislative and community programs.

Prior to joining the WSLC staff, Sims served as the Legislative and Political Action Field Coordinator for the Washington Federation of State Employees, AFSCME Council 28 (WFSE), where she was responsible for member education, communication, and mobilization around legislative issues and political campaigns. She was a WFSE member, shop steward, elected union officer, and union staffer from 2002-15.

Kathryn Edin

Princeton University

Edin is one of the nation’s leading poverty researchers. A qualitative and mixed-method researcher, she has taken on key mysteries about the urban poor that have not been fully answered by quantitative work: How do single mothers possibly survive on welfare? Why don’t more go to work? Why do they end up as single mothers in the first place? Where are the fathers and why do they disengage from their children’s lives? How have the lives of the single mothers changed as a result of welfare reform? The hallmark of her research is her direct, in-depth observations of the lives of low-income women, men, and children.

Gary Evans

Cornell University

Professor Evans is an environmental and developmental psychologist interested in how the physical environment affects human health and well being among children. His specific areas of expertise include the environment of childhood poverty, children’s environments (housing, schools, playgrounds, toys), cumulative risk and child development, environmental stressors, and the development of children’s environmental attitudes and behaviors.

Olga Miranda

SEIU 87

Olga is President of SEIU Local 87 in San Francisco. The SEIU was founded in 1921 in Chicago as the Building Services Employees Union (BSEU); its first members were janitors, elevator operators, and window washers.
Today SEIU is the fastest-growing union in North America, uniting workers in the United States, Canada and Puerto Rico. Over 25 percent of our members whom identify as immigrants – a constant tribute to the union’s roots. From the start, SEIU has embraced its heritage as a union of immigrants and has stood on the frontline of immigrant justice.

“People open their lives and homes to us, for me it becomes not only a privilege but a responsibility to make sure their stories are told. We have to be brutally honest and empathetic when telling their stories. When it comes to filming families, the right thing to do is be their advocate and make sure people don’t look away. “
Jillian Hurley
Producer

Stephanie Porta

Organize Florida

As a community organizer, Stephanie Porta has spent the last 15 years working to support Florida’s low income communities in their fight for equity and dignity. Her work has led to raising Florida’s minimum wage in 2004, passing police accountability reforms, winning foreclosure prevention programs, affordable utility campaigns, electing progressive officials and much more.

In 2010, Stephanie co-founded Organize Florida to work on the needs of Florida’s low and moderate income communities and now acts as Executive Director. The membership organization has grown quickly and has membership in 17 counties across mid-Florida. In 2014, Stephanie championed efforts to pass Earned Sick Time in Orange County, and in 2016 supported outreach efforts to more than two million voters across Florida. Stephanie has been recognized by the Orlando Sentinel, Orlando Weekly, Orlando Magazine & Orlando Women’s Magazine for leadership on government transparency and issues facing the working poor.

Beth Babcock

Empathways

Elisabeth Babcock (Beth) is the President and CEO of Economic Mobility Pathways (EMPath), an international charitable organization dedicated to creating new pathways to economic independence for low-income families. EMPath uses its unique “action-tank” business model to design, build, and test new approaches for creating economic mobility and then shares them with other organizations and governments.

Mike Buchman

Solid Ground

Mike is the Communications Director for Solid Ground in Seattle, WA. Solid Ground works to end poverty and undo racism and other oppressions that are root causes of poverty. Solid Ground envisions a community beyond poverty and oppression where all people have equitable opportunity to thrive.

Stephanie Kelton

Stony Brook University

Stephanie is a leading authority on Modern Monetary Theory, a new approach to economics that is taking the world by storm. She is considered one of the most important voices influencing the policy debate today.

Her forthcoming book, The Deficit Myth: Modern Monetary Theory and the Birth of the People’s Economy (June 9, 2020), shows how to break free of the flawed thinking that has hamstrung policymakers around the world.

 

Lawrence Katz

Harvard University

Lawrence F. Katz is the Elisabeth Allison Professor of Economics at Harvard University and a Research Associate of the National Bureau of Economic Research.  His research focuses on issues in labor economics and the economics of social problems. He is the author (with Claudia Goldin) of The Race between Education and Technology (Harvard University Press, 2008), a history of U.S. economic inequality and the roles of technological change and the pace of educational advance in affecting the wage structure. 

 

Stacy Mitchell

ILSR

Stacy Mitchell is co-director of the Institute for Local Self-Reliance and directs its Independent Business Initiative, which produces research and analysis, and partners with a broad range of allies to design and implement policies to reverse corporate concentration and strengthen local enterprise.

Mitchell has also written for The AtlanticBloombergWashington Monthly, and Wall Street Journal.  She’s the author of the book Big-Box Swindle. Her perspective and research are frequently cited in news media and she’s appeared on several national radio shows and podcasts, including NPR’s On The Media and Chris Hayes’ Why Is This Happening?

 

"Income inequality is the greatest problem facing America today. It effects our other two major inequality issues, racial inequality and gender inequality. Income inequality must be remedied or America will inevitably collapse into a Banana Republic without drastic legislative and societal action."
Dave Pederson
Producer
"How the war on poverty became the war against the poor."
Dave Pederson
Producer

Jacob Hacker

Yale University

Jacob S. Hacker is Stanley Resor Professor of Political Science and Director of the Institution for Social and Policy Studies at Yale University. A regular media commentator and policy adviser, he is the author or co-author of five books, numerous journal articles, and a wide range of popular writings on American politics and public policy. His most recent book, written with Paul Pierson, is American Amnesia: How the War on Government Led Us to Forget What Made America Prosper—a New York Times Book Review Editor’s Choice and a best business book of 2016 according to the management magazine Strategy+Business.